Guide
SCORM 1.2 vs SCORM 2004
SCORM is a set of rules that lets an online course and a learning management system (LMS) work together.
When you publish a course from an authoring tool, you often choose between SCORM 1.2 and SCORM 2004.
This guide explains the differences that matter when you choose.
Published October 24, 2026 by the Openbox team. Updated October 31, 2026.
The short answer
SCORM 2004 tells the LMS two things separately: whether a learner finished, and whether they passed. SCORM 1.2 puts both into one status.1
So if your course has a test, and you need to know both, choose SCORM 2004.
If your course has no test, either version can record that a learner finished.
Check which versions your LMS accepts before you publish.
Completion and pass or fail
In SCORM 1.2, a course reports passed, failed or completed in a single value, cmi.core.lesson_status.1
In SCORM 2004, completion and success are two values: cmi.completion_status and cmi.success_status.1
| What the LMS learns | SCORM 1.2 | SCORM 2004 |
|---|---|---|
| Did they finish? | cmi.core.lesson_status | cmi.completion_status: completed, incomplete, not attempted or unknown |
| Did they pass? | The same value, cmi.core.lesson_status | cmi.success_status: passed, failed or unknown |
| The pass mark | cmi.student_data.mastery_score | cmi.scaled_passing_score |
| How far through they are | Not available | cmi.progress_measure |
With one value, the LMS can't tell whether a learner who failed the test also finished the course. Two values remove that doubt.
Scores
Both versions can report a raw score, with a minimum and a maximum.1
SCORM 2004 adds a scaled score, cmi.score.scaled, from -1 to 1. A score of 0.95 means 95 percent.21
Saved progress
Courses save where a learner is, so they can pick up later. This is called suspend data.
In SCORM 2004 4th Edition, an LMS must be able to store at least 64,000 characters of suspend data.2
Long courses with many screens or branching paths can need that much room.
Some SCORM 1.2 courses save more than the 1.2 rules allow. Openbox keeps up to 65,536 characters for them, so they still resume where the learner left off.
Sequencing
SCORM 2004 adds Sequencing and Navigation. These are rules inside the course file that decide the order learners move through its activities.3
A course that plays as one unit, with its own menu, doesn't need them.
Openbox can't run SCORM 2004 sequencing rules yet. If a file depends on them, Openbox stops it at upload and says why. Export the course again without sequencing rules, then upload the new file.
How a course talks to the LMS
A SCORM 1.2 course looks for an object named API and calls LMSInitialize to start. A SCORM 2004 course looks for API_1484_11 and calls Initialize.45
Your authoring tool writes this part for you. It matters only if you build courses by hand.
What about xAPI and cmi5?
xAPI is a specification for recording learning activity as statements, from inside or outside an LMS. Advanced Distributed Learning publishes its earlier versions, and version 2.0 is published through IEEE.61
cmi5 is a set of rules for using xAPI with an LMS, so a course can be launched and tracked much as SCORM courses are.7
cmi5 and xAPI packages are available in Openbox too.
Choosing when you publish
Your authoring tool usually asks which version to publish.
- Choose SCORM 2004 (3rd or 4th edition) when your course has a test, or saves a lot of progress.
- Choose SCORM 1.2 when the LMS you use accepts only SCORM 1.2.
- Turn off sequencing options unless you know your LMS runs them.
Openbox accepts SCORM 1.2 and SCORM 2004 3rd and 4th edition files. Earlier SCORM 2004 editions are stopped at upload, with the reason.
SCORM in Openbox
When you upload a SCORM file, Openbox shows what it found: the package type, the title in the file, the start file, the parts and any pass mark.
For each attempt, course analytics show the answers the package reported: the learner's response, the correct response, the result and the time taken.
You don't need SCORM to build a course in Openbox. Course Studio builds lessons, video, questions and tests without separate authoring software. See how Course Studio works.
Before you upload, check your file with our free SCORM package checker. It reads the file on your own device.
Sources
- Advanced Distributed Learning (ADL). Experience API SCORM Profile. Checked October 31, 2026.
- Advanced Distributed Learning (ADL). SCORM 2004 4th Edition Sample Run-Time Environment: data model (SCORM_2004_DM.java). Checked October 31, 2026.
- Advanced Distributed Learning (ADL). SCORM 2004 4th Edition Sample Run-Time Environment Version 1.1.1 Readme: Introduction. Checked October 24, 2026.
- Advanced Distributed Learning (ADL). SCORM 1.2 APIWrapper.js (SCORM-to-xAPI-Wrapper). Checked October 24, 2026.
- Advanced Distributed Learning (ADL). SCORM 2004 APIWrapper.js (SCORM-to-xAPI-Wrapper). Checked October 24, 2026.
- Advanced Distributed Learning (ADL). xAPI Specification. Checked October 24, 2026.
- AICC cmi5 project. The cmi5 Project (CMI-5_Spec_Current). Checked October 24, 2026.
Keep reading
See how Openbox tracks required training
Try the sample with no sign-up, or see what each plan costs.